The Real Cost of Asking a Friend To “Just Pop In”

The Real Cost of Asking a Friend To “Just Pop In”

We’ve all done it.

You’ve finally booked a break. Flights are paid, bags are half-packed, the dog is suspicious, and you fire off that message:

“Hey! Could you just pop in and feed the pets while we’re away? It’ll only take a few minutes 😊”

You hit send. You feel a bit guilty, but hey, it’s only food bowls and a quick cuddle, right?

Except… it’s not.

Let’s talk about what actually happens when we outsource pet and house care to “favours” - and why, in many cases, paying a sitter is kinder for your friend and better for your fur-kids.

The “Just Pop In” Favour Loop

On paper, it looks simple:

  • Hand over a spare key
  • Scribble some feeding instructions
  • Say “Thanks, you’re a lifesaver!”
  • Drop off a slab of chocolate / bottle of wine afterwards

In real life, it looks more like this:

  • Awkward keys: You’re leaving at 5am and your friend can only do 7pm the night before. Cue key handover dance.
  • Vague expectations: Are they coming once a day? Twice? Are they staying a bit to keep the dog company or literally in-and-out in 3 minutes?
  • Unspoken responsibilities:
    • “If the alarm goes off…”
    • “If there’s a burst pipe…”
    • “If the dog seems off…”

None of this is written down. It’s all floating around in the realm of “I’m sure they’ll figure it out.”

  • Airport brain: You’re at the gate thinking, Did I actually tell them where the backup food is?
     Did I explain the weird gate latch?
     Did I mention that the cat will pretend she hasn’t eaten?

Everyone is being lovely. Everyone is trying. But no one really knows where the lines are.

The Hidden Costs No One Talks About

Favour-based pet care doesn’t just cost you a slab of chocolate.

1. Social debt

No matter how chilled your friend is, there’s a tiny social ledger that just updated:

  • They’re now feeding, cleaning up, locking up, checking alarms.
  • You’re now vaguely obligated to… what? Babysit? Help them move? Watch their 3-hour school concert?

No one says it out loud, but it’s there.

2. Silent resentment (the “contempt brewing” bit)

Your friend might love your animals - but they also have a life.

What happens when:

  • They get invited away for the weekend while they’re supposed to be “popping in” for you?
  • They’re exhausted after a long day, but still have to drive across town to feed your crew?
  • Their partner is muttering, “Why are we chained to someone else’s pets again?”

Suddenly, they’re choosing between their own plans and your animals. Even if they can say no, they might feel like they shouldn’t. That’s where that quiet contempt can creep in.

“Sure, we can’t go away, because we’re sitting Jo’s animals… again.”

No one wants their beloved pet to become the reason a friend feels trapped.

3. Zero accountability, zero backup

Let’s be honest:

If your friend:

  • Forgets a visit
  • Comes hours later than planned
  • Misses a message from you

…there’s not a lot you can do except feel anxious and awkward. You’re hardly going to send a strongly worded email with the subject: FORMAL COMPLAINT: YOU FED MY CAT LATE.

When Your Backup Needs a Backup

You’re already away. You’re in another city (or country), living your best life, when you get this message:

“Hey, so sorry, but we’ve been invited away for the weekend!”
 “We might still be able to do the pets, but it will be a bit of a schlep…”

Now what?

  • They feel bad saying no.
  • You feel bad asking them to say yes.
  • The animals are in the middle, waiting for dinner.

So you’re now:

  • On Airbnb Wi-Fi
  • Scrolling through your contacts
  • Trying to line up a backup for your backup
  • Explaining security codes, feeding routines and gate dramas over WhatsApp voice notes

All from afar. This is the very opposite of “relaxing holiday.”

Why Paying a Sitter Is Actually Kinder

On the surface, asking a friend is “free” and hiring a sitter costs money. But when you look a bit deeper, paying a sitter is often the kinder, more adult option - for everyone involved.

Kinder to your friends

  • No social debt. They can just be your friends, not unpaid staff.
  • No resentment. They’re not quietly giving up weekends or evenings because they feel obligated.
  • Clear boundaries. You’re not mixing friendship with “sort-of-a-job-but-not-really.”

Invite them for a braai when you’re back instead. Much more fun for everyone.

Kinder to your pets

A professional sitter:

  • Expect to build their day around your pet’s needs.
  • Has time to stay, play, and keep them company (not just rush in, pour kibble, rush out).
  • Knows to look out for warning signs: behaviour changes, eating changes, or that “something’s off” vibe.

Your pets care more about routine, presence and calm than about who brings the food.

Kinder to you

  • Clarity: You know exactly what you’re paying for and what’s included.
  • Reliability: This is their actual job, not an afterthought.
  • Backup: If something changes, you have a platform and a structure to help you find another sitter - not a panicked WhatsApp fishing trip.

How Housepawty Does It Differently

At Housepawty, we’re trying to take the guilt, guesswork and awkwardness out of pet and house sitting.

Here’s how we help:

1. Clear sitter profiles

You can see:

  • Who they are
  • Where they’re based
  • What experience they have
  • What services they offer (live-in, pop-ins, walkies, etc.)

No more vague, “My cousin’s friend once did cat sitting…”

2. Agreed expectations up front

Before you confirm a booking, you can:

  • Agree how many visits per day
  • Confirm walkies, playtime, sleepover or not
  • Share all your pet’s quirks, routines and little diva demands
  • Clarify house stuff: bins, plants, pool, alarm, gate, deliveries

Everyone knows where they stand. In writing.

3. Proper grown-up accountability

Because there’s a platform between you:

  • There’s a clear record of dates, times and services.
  • No one is relying on “I thought you said…?”
  • Both sides know this is a paid, professional arrangement — not a guilt-trip favour.

4. Less panic, more pawty

Need help last minute?
 Need someone to step in for a specific stretch?
 Want to build a relationship with a regular sitter so you can travel without that knot in your stomach?

That’s literally why we built this.

Time To Retire the Guilt-Trip WhatsApp

Look, we’re not saying you should never ask a friend for help again. Community is beautiful. Neighbours helping neighbours is part of the good stuff of life.

But when it comes to:

  • Longer trips
  • Multiple animals
  • Anxious pets
  • Busy friends who also deserve a holiday

…“just pop in?” might be costing more than you think.

Let your friends be your friends. Let your pets have someone whose actual job is to love on them while you’re away.  And let you go on holiday without trying to manage a backup for your backup from a hotel lobby.

Back to blog